wfn.org | [LCMSNews]Panel lifts Benke suspension

["LCMS e-News" <LCMSENEWS@lcms.org>]

	 <http://www.lcms.org>
e-News
	LCMS News

	PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS E-MAIL MESSAGE! This message comes
from a "Send Only" Mailbox that does not recognize replies.

	May 12, 2003 ..................... LCMSNews -- No. 40

	Dispute panel lifts Benke suspension

	A dispute resolution panel has lifted the suspension of Dr.
David Benke, who has returned to work as president of the Synod's
Atlantic District.

	Benke was suspended last June by LCMS Second Vice President
Wallace Schulz in response to complaints filed months earlier by 18 LCMS
pastors and three congregations. The complaints said Benke's
participation in "A Prayer for America," a post-Sept. 11, 2001, event at
Yankee Stadium, constituted unscriptural worship with non-Christians,
sin against the First and Second Commandments, public defense of false
doctrine and violation of the Synod's Constitution and Bylaws.

	Benke appealed the suspension, which has now been lifted. The
three-member panel's decision was unanimous.

	"On the basis of the testimony and evidence received, the Panel
concludes that there is not sufficient reason or evidence according to
the Synod's Constitution and Bylaws for suspending Rev. Benke.
Therefore, the Panel concludes that the decision of Rev. Schulz for
expulsion of Rev. Benke under Article XIII of the Constitution of the
Synod is not substantiated," the dispute resolution panel wrote. "The
suspension of Rev. Benke is lifted and his LCMS membership in good
standing is continued."

	The panel's decision is dated April 10. Under the Synod's
Bylaws, Benke, Schulz or Synod President Gerald Kieschnick had 30 days
to appeal it. None of the parties did.

	"Rev. Benke's participation [in A Prayer for America'] was
neither a rejection of nor a challenge to the Synod's Fellowship
position and practice, but a discretionary response to a quite
extraordinary set of circumstances in a quite unordinary event -- a
terrorist attack on the United States of America, specifically in New
York City and the parochial area of St. Peter's Lutheran Church, New
York, New York, and the Atlantic District of the LCMS," the panel wrote.

	Benke is pastor of St. Peter's congregation in Brooklyn as well
as Atlantic District president.

	Kieschnick announced the panel's decision today (May 12).

	"Much time, energy and attention have been expended on this case
throughout the past 18 months," Kieschnick wrote in a memo to the
members of The Lutheran Church--Missouri Synod. "The personal lives,
professional careers and respective constituencies of two duly elected
officers of the Synod (Dr. Benke and Dr. Schulz) have been affected in
ways that they alone can fully comprehend."

	Kieschnick wrote that, as Synod president, he is "grateful that
this particular case is concluded."

	Benke commented today that he is "proud" to serve in the
Missouri Synod.

	"The Word of God says, always be prepared to give defense of the
hope that is within you, but do so with gentleness and respect,'" Benke
said, quoting 1 Peter 3:15. "Yankee Stadium on Sept. 23, 2001, was the
right place at the right time for the right witness to be given in a
prayer for healing in the precious Name of Jesus.

	"I am proud to serve in a denomination, The Lutheran
Church--Missouri Synod, that encourages such witness through its
understanding of the Scripture and through its own decisions," Benke
continued. "And I am thankful for the process, no matter its duration,
that helped to ascertain that Christian witness in any and all
circumstance is to be seen as a God-given opportunity and not to be
avoided."

	Schulz said he disagrees with the panel's decision to lift
Benke's suspension but told Synod Secretary Raymond Hartwig that he
would not appeal it. "Our Synod has been through enough of this
process," Schulz wrote to Hartwig, who administers the
dispute-resolution process.

	In the May 11 letter to Hartwig, which Schulz made public today,
he wrote that "the Panel's decision makes over 25 references to the
controversial resolution and an additional 35 references to bylaws *but
fails to make even a single reference to the Holy Scriptures*!" The
emphasis is Schulz's.

	His reference is to Resolution 3-07A adopted by the 2001 Synod
convention. It commends "for continued use and guidance" two documents
on church-fellowship issues. The panel said it heard testimony that
Kieschnick approved Benke's decision to participate in the Yankee
Stadium event on the basis of that resolution.

	"In other words," Schulz wrote, "even though this case involves
a very serious offense against God's First Commandment and must
therefore be dealt with on the basis of God's Word, *the Panel has
decided to rule on the basis of a man-made resolution*!

	"In its decision the Panel has clearly violated the Constitution
of The Lutheran Church--Missouri Synod and sinned against the Word of
God, since Article VIII of the LCMS Constitution states All matters of
doctrine and conscience shall be decided *only* by the Word of God,'"
Schulz continued.

	"If the Panel's decision is permitted to stand unchallenged, its
impact will reach far beyond the Benke case, fundamentally changing our
Synod and leading it to resolve spiritual issues on the basis of men's
opinions rather than God's Word," Schulz wrote.

	The dispute resolution panel's decision does not agree, however,
that such resolutions reflect human opinion rather than Holy Scripture.
It quotes a letter from Dr. Samuel Nafzger, executive director of the
Synod's Commission on Theology and Church Relations, regarding how the
authority of Scripture relates to the Synod's doctrinal resolutions:

	"The Synod is not elevating resolutions which it adopts over the
Scriptures when it requires its members to honor and uphold such
doctrinal resolutions and statements," Nafzger wrote to the panel. "This
is rather a recognition of what it is that the majority of its members
understand the Scriptures to teach."

	Nafzger wrote that the Synod has a procedure for dissent should
anyone believe a resolution to be contrary to Scripture. But, he added,
"the members of the Synod are not free to disregard synodically adopted
doctrinal resolutions and statements or to teach and act contrary to
them as they carry out their ministries."

	The panel wrote that "the collective will of the Synod is
expressed in Resolution 3-07A. Until the Synod itself adopts a more
definitive resolution, cases of discretion will be managed in accordance
with 3-07A and the corresponding ecclesiastical supervision. In such
cases, the Resolution does not encourage the bringing of charges and
possible dismissal, but patience, putting the best construction on
everything {charity}, and the opportunity for continued study and
discussion as per (LCMS Bylaw) 2.39 c.

	"Where the Synod has provided even a minimal measure of
guidance, we should not stand in judgment of one another in matters of
discretionary and extra ordinary nature, especially in matters of
tragedy and emotional distress when and where there is no intention to
belittle or defy the positions of Synod," the panel said.

	The entire 14-page decision of the dispute resolution panel is
available on the Web at www.lcms.org/president/disputedecision.asp
<http://www.lcms.org/president/disputedecision.asp>  .

	****************************************

	LCMSNews is published by the News and Information Division,
Board for Communication Services, of The Lutheran Church--Missouri
Synod. If you have questions or comments about this LCMSNews release,
contact Joe Isenhower Jr. at joe.isenhower@lcms.org or (314) 996-1231,
or Paula Schlueter Ross at paula.ross@lcms.org or (314) 996 1230.

	To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your e-mail address for
LCMSNews, go to the following Web address: www.lcms.org/enews
<http://www.lcms.org/enews>  .

	****************************************

	  This Edition of "LCMS News" e-News is provided by:

	Board for Communication Services
Contact Editor <http://www.lcms.org/enews/contact_editor.asp?title=LCMS
News&editorid=6>

-

		To subscribe to or unsubscribe from this Newsletter and
many others, please visit LCMS e-News <http://www.lcms.org/enews> .

MessageId= 504
  _____

) Copyright 2003 The Lutheran Church--Missouri Synod.
<http://www.lcms.org>
No reproduction without consent. All rights reserved.